March 18, 2008
-
A Different Generation of Asians
When our generation thinks about becoming parents, we think about how we want a relationship of open communication with our children. When our children are younger, we want to teach them the way that is right, but when they are older — when they have become adults, we want to release them into the Lord’s hands and walk beside them as friends. When they are adults, we want to have intimate conversation with them, we want to laugh with them and cry with them, and give them the freedom to make wise or foolish decisions (they are adults after all, and we want to treat them as such). That is a high value of our generation.
The generation before us, however, has a different value. They see themselves as the teachers of their children – no matter how old their children may be. They believe that if they provide for the children when they are young, then they have successfully shown love. When their children are older, they want to continue to share from the knowledge of their years and experience.
Our generation longs for authenticity and relationship. So in seeking this, we share honestly with our parents. We take them with us on our journey of processing through dreams and decisions, and in our more courageous moments, we even tell them our doubts, because we long for them to be our friends, to just listen and allow us to make our choices and to be supportive of our decisions as our friends would. Our parents, however, perceive these moments as another opportunity to teach us, instruct us and thereby, to give us their ‘wisdom’. In their minds, this is their ‘job’, their responsibility, and we will never be as wise as them. But, often, the feedback we get from them feels more like criticisms and commands tied up with an expectation of obedience (and not merely ‘suggestions’), and we sigh because it doesn’t seem to us that they really believe that we have matured. Their desire to maintain the role of ‘teacher’ in our lives feels like lack of faith that we have ever grown up.
Some of us struggle long and hard to prove ourselves to them – to help them understand that we really have grown up, that they need to stop treating us like children and more like adults. Others of us give up all together and choose to exclude them from much of our musings, our doubts, our thoughts — we shrug it off, saying that it doesn’t matter that we are not taking them on our journeys, but all the while we feel that something is not quite right. The reality is that our hearts are still aching for that close, intimate relationship with our parents — the kind of relationship that we value so much and they know so little about. But we continue to be at such cross-purposes: We want authenticity and friendship; they want to be our teachers.
So is there a middle ground, a way of mutual satisfaction of expectations? For awhile now, I thought I had found it. But then there are days when this miscalculation flies back at me and tells me I didn’t have it quite right after all. So I am still searching. What about you?
Comments (9)
agreed, and further, i proprose that perhaps this doesn’t apply only to asians, but this entire generation of young people who are becoming increasingly postmodern… perhaps our children will want something entirely different, and be their own generation of people looking for things that we could not–and did not want to–provide. perhaps too, we’ve yet to shuffle off the ‘sins of the parents” passed down (third and fourth generations?) as of yet. in any case, my point is that this “different generation” isn’t just happening to displaced citizens of different countries in America… it’s even happening within the country, and others, including the East… what do you think?
yeah strange… my parents basically changed to subscribe to the authenticity/friendship model… at least with me. I think I would just avoid them if they still had the teaching model… visit now and then, but not really share stuff with them. Not saying that’s the correct way of doing it or the most relationally beneficial… just that that is probably what I would end up doing.
I second Daniel’s experience. That’s more or less how I grew up and learned to think and act independently of the mainstream masses. I suppose that may partly be why my perspective on Christianity is influenced towards the same end. I don’t believe in moralizing or teaching down at people (as a traditionalist parent might do), but learning to make it more relevant and assist them in finding their true purpose and place in the kingdom (a more genuine friend approach).
my parents still have the teaching model. They try not to show it, but I know their mentality is there.
sooo well put. i don’t have a response yet, but i wanted to say… man what a way with words!
I think my mom’s situation is a little different because her parents were so old school and she was born and raised in LA. So while she saw other girls burning their bras and backpacking around Europe, she was always at home, the dutiful, obedient daughter. So outwardly she’s always encouraging me to do adventurous new things, while inwardly cringing at what could happen to me because I’m just a kid (at age 30).
I think that’s incredibly insightful of you and true. It’s nice to know that I’m not the only one that feels the way I do about desiring authenticity and friendship. I think Tim and I lucked out though, our parents are pretty good at allowing us to express ourselves and being supportive no matter what decisions we make (even if they’re not the best or wisest decision). I’m just wishing I could find authenticity and friendship in every relationship (really it’s just the right way to interact with people if you really want them to learn anything from you)
. Such a dreamer I am.
hey, i tried buying it but I think it was out of stock!! window popped up and said ” unable to add to cart… not enough in stock…” oh well..
@lily -
Hi Lily, I think the magazine is not yet in stock — meaning that we got the advanced copy, so it will probably be in stock in a few weeks. I’ll write to the editor to find out! Thanks for your support!